The Super Bowl Construction Ad That Was Banned From Broadcast
The controversial Super Bowl Ad proposed by 84 Lumber is revealed.
Mon February 06, 2017 - National Edition MARISSA PAYNE
A Super Bowl ad imagined by the family-owned company 84 Lumber decided to tackle a controversial subject in its first Super Bowl ad. But it wasn't exactly how the company originally planned it, however.
In the ad's initial iteration, a Mexican mother and daughter, who appear to be on their way to the United States, come across a depiction of an imposing border wall, reminiscent of the proposed border wall.
"Ignoring the border wall and the conversation around immigration that's taking place in the media and at every kitchen table in America just didn't seem right," said Rob Shapiro, the chief client officer at Brunner, the agency that worked with 84 Lumber to come up with the ad. "If everyone else is trying to avoid controversy, isn't that the time when brands should take a stand for what they believe in?"
But while 84 Lumber believed in its message, Fox, which aired Sunday's game, thought it was a little too controversial.
"Fox would not let us air 'the wall,' " Schapiro said. "Of course we were disappointed," added Amy Smiley, 84 Lumber's director of marketing. "But ultimately, it's their network and their decision."
Smiley said Fox expressed "concerns about some of the elements" in the initial spot and so when the network ultimately rejected the ad last month, she "understood their reasons."
Smiley said current events played a role in the ad's rejection, especially all the talk about the proposed wall.
"…[T]he conversation in the media exploded around this topic, and it evolved into something controversial that made Fox a little too uncomfortable," she said.
Ultimately, 84 Lumber and Brunner came up with an edit that Fox finally approved and aired on Sunday. Gone is the wall, replaced by a less imposing barbed-wire fence at what appears to be the border.
Called "The Journey Begins," the ad depicts a Mexican woman and her daughter readying to travel to the United States. Under the old version, the two arrive at the border wall, where their quest appears to end in a cliffhanger.
In the new ending, the mother and daughter are shown holding hands while "See the conclusion at Journey84.com "; appears across the screen.
Viewers who go to the website won't just find the conclusion to the pair's journey, but also the original, rejected ad.
"We all felt too strongly about the message to leave it on the editing room floor," Smiley said.
"The commercial that will air during the Super Bowl does not have the ending we originally wanted, but the message has not changed," Schapiro said. "Our message is that America is the land of opportunity and 84 Lumber is the company of opportunity."
For the full story, visit the original article posted on the Washington Post news site at http://url.ie/11oe8.
Construction Equipment Guide
470 Maryland Drive
Fort Washington, PA 19034
Construction Equipment Guide covers the nation with its four regional newspapers, offering construction and industry news and information along with new and used construction equipment for sale from dealers in your area. Now we extend those services and information to the internet. Making it as easy as possible to find the news and equipment that you need and want.
Contents Copyrighted 2022, by Construction Equipment Guide, which is a Registered Trademark, registered in the U.S. Patent Office. Registration number 0957323. All rights reserved, nothing may be reprinted or reproduced (including framing) in whole or part without written permission from the publisher. All editorial material, photographs, drawings, letters, and other material will be treated as unconditionally assigned for publication and copyright purposes and are subject to Construction Equipment Guide’s unrestricted right to edit and comment editorially. Contributor articles do not necessarily reflect the policy or opinions of this publication.